Guide
Single joint expert valuation in divorce and shareholder disputes
Updated
When a valuation will be argued about, the rules change, and so does the cost. So does whose side the valuer is on, the most misunderstood part of this work.
Ask for a valuation report Two minutes of questions, then we reply to you directly about the work and its cost for that specific purpose.
The expert's duty is to the court, not to you
Part 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules is short and unambiguous on this point. Rule 35.3 states: "(1) It is the duty of experts to help the court on matters within their expertise. (2) This duty overrides any obligation to the person from whom experts have received instructions or by whom they are paid" (CPR Part 35).
Paying the expert does not buy you the answer you want. An expert who behaves as though it does damages the case they were instructed to support.
You need the court's permission, and a costs estimate
Rule 35.4 provides that "No party may call an expert or put in evidence an expert's report without the court's permission". When applying for permission the parties "must provide an estimate of the costs of the proposed expert evidence". They must also identify the field in which it is required and the issues it will address.
Rule 35.1 sets the overall limit: "Expert evidence shall be restricted to that which is reasonably required to resolve the proceedings."
In practice this means the fee estimate is not a private matter between you and the valuer. It goes to the court as part of the permission application, so a quote that is vague about scope is a problem before the work even starts.
The single joint expert valuation
- What it is
- CPR 35.2(2) defines a single joint expert as "an expert instructed to prepare a report for the court on behalf of two or more of the parties". Under rule 35.7, where two or more parties wish to submit expert evidence on an issue, the court may direct that it be given by a single joint expert, and if the parties cannot agree who that should be, the court may decide.
- Why it matters to cost
- One expert instead of two is the largest single saving available in a disputed valuation. It is common in financial remedy proceedings on divorce, where the business is an asset to be understood rather than a battleground in itself.
- When two experts happen
- Where the valuation itself is the dispute, for example an unfair prejudice claim over the price of a minority holding, each side may have permission for its own expert. Rule 35.4(3A) notes that on the small claims and fast tracks permission will normally be given for only one expert on a particular issue.
Disputes over a divorce valuation: Family Procedure Rules Part 25
Financial remedy proceedings on divorce are family proceedings. So the rules on experts are in Part 25 of the Family Procedure Rules rather than CPR Part 35, though they read much the same. Rule 25.3 repeats that the expert's duty is to help the court, overriding any obligation to whoever instructed or paid them.
Rule 25.4 provides that "A person may not without the permission of the court put expert evidence (in any form) before the court". Permission is given only if the court thinks the evidence "is necessary to assist the court to resolve the proceedings".
Rule 25.7: the application states field, issues and "whether the expert evidence could be obtained from a single joint expert" (FPR Part 25, read 2 November 2026).
Where both spouses want evidence on the same issue, rule 25.11 lets the court direct a single joint expert, and choose one if the parties cannot agree. Rule 25.12:
- puts the instructions in a jointly agreed letter;
- lets the court limit the expert's fees and expenses before the expert is instructed;
- makes both parties jointly and severally liable for those fees unless the court directs otherwise (FPR Part 25, read 2 November 2026).
So the fee is shared, and it can be capped by the court.
Partner dispute valuation
A dispute between business partners or shareholders that reaches court is civil proceedings, so CPR Part 35 applies. That means permission under rule 35.4, a costs estimate with the application, and possibly a single joint expert under rule 35.7 (CPR Part 35).
What usually separates a partner dispute valuation from a divorce one: the price of the outgoing partner's share is the dispute itself. So each side more often argues for its own expert.
What makes a dispute valuation expensive
- Disclosure. Getting the underlying financial records out of a company you are in dispute with is a process, not a request.
- Valuation date arguments. In a shareholder dispute the date at which the shares are valued can matter more than the methodology.
- Minority discounts. Whether a discount applies to a minority holding is frequently the whole argument, and it is a legal question as much as a valuation one.
- Meetings of experts. Where two experts are instructed, they typically meet before a hearing to narrow the issues, and a joint statement follows.
- Supplementary reports and questions. CPR 35 allows written questions to an expert; answering them is chargeable work.
- Attendance at a hearing. Days in court, and the preparation for them, are usually quoted separately.
What to ask before instructing
- Has the court given permission for expert evidence, and on what issues?
- Is this a single joint expert instruction, or a party-appointed one?
- What does the fee cover, and what is charged separately: written questions, a joint statement, a supplementary report, a hearing?
- What is the expert's relevant experience of this sector and of giving evidence?
- Will the report contain the statement required at the end of an expert's report that the expert understands and has complied with their duty to the court?
This is a description of published court rules, not legal advice. Proceedings differ, and which rules apply to your case, and how the court will use them, is a question for your solicitor.